Page 1 of 2

any jazz bands that dont allow certain instrements????

Posted: Mon Nov 17, 2003 8:31 am
by they_call_me_tuba_sam
I go to loara and we have been trying to start a jazz band for a while. Our band director keeps telling us that we cant have and tubas, french horn, flutes (which kinda makes sence), and clarinets!!! does this happen at other schools as well??????? i dont think that its fair. He says there isnt any music written for clarinets, i told him to go tell Benny Goodman that.

Posted: Mon Nov 17, 2003 1:41 pm
by TMRsaxyDM
i dont see why it makes sence that there are no flutes.. ive heard many many flute jazz players.. but its the same at our school, we dont have any flutes or clarinets... i think the reason is our director cant find music that is easy enough for us to play that has clairnet/flute parts writen.. so i dont know.. give your director a break..

Posted: Mon Nov 17, 2003 3:57 pm
by LovableSheep
Flutes and clarinets? That's what saxes are for. Ever heard of doubling? Real sax players can double on flute and clarinet 8-)

Posted: Mon Nov 17, 2003 5:57 pm
by Starky
Our Jazz band dosnt allow french horn, flute, clarinet, tuba, and baritones (all baritones gotta learn trombone).

jazzzzzz

Posted: Mon Nov 17, 2003 6:24 pm
by piccoboeMP
At Moorpark we have people play the normal jazz instruments and then double if the band director needs the parts...I play bari sax in jazz band but i double on flute...

clarinets in jazz band

Posted: Tue Nov 18, 2003 5:35 pm
by altohack
The only reason clarinets aren't allowed in jazz band is benny goodman.
Benny Goodman blew ALL the clarinets away... and no one, I mean, NO ONE has been able to compare to him. He's the only real famous jazz clarinetist, and since him people have stopped playing clarinet in jazz band. But by George is Benny Goodman awesome.

All of those who don't know what I'm talking about, download sing sing sing.

Posted: Tue Nov 18, 2003 9:58 pm
by saxydm05
for the most part most jazz charts dont have flute/clarinet parts because its not a normal jazz instrument. depending on the composer/arranger's style a chart might call for some weird instruments. by the way ive heard of using a tuba to play a 4th trombone part

Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2003 12:28 am
by eternalbando
LovableSheep wrote:Flutes and clarinets? That's what saxes are for. Ever heard of doubling? Real sax players can double on flute and clarinet 8-)
I agree that doubling is common, but I dunno about the "real sax players" thing. I know some pretty good sax players who don't double...Anyways, our school doesn't allow flutes, clarinets, french horns, tubas, bassoons, oboes, etc. into jazz unless they primarily use a "jazz" instrument for jazz. but most of them play other instruments, too...hehe.

Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2003 6:27 pm
by LovableSheep
edbandchick wrote:
LovableSheep wrote:Flutes and clarinets? That's what saxes are for. Ever heard of doubling? Real sax players can double on flute and clarinet 8-)
I agree that doubling is common, but I dunno about the "real sax players" thing. I know some pretty good sax players who don't double...Anyways, our school doesn't allow flutes, clarinets, french horns, tubas, bassoons, oboes, etc. into jazz unless they primarily use a "jazz" instrument for jazz. but most of them play other instruments, too...hehe.
I'm just kidding around about the "real sax players" thing. I'm actually a clarinet player and I learned sax so I could be in jazz band.

Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2003 9:56 pm
by TMR Quint Kid
TMRsaxyDM wrote:i dont see why it makes sence that there are no flutes.. ive heard many many flute jazz players.. but its the same at our school, we dont have any flutes or clarinets... i think the reason is our director cant find music that is easy enough for us to play that has clairnet/flute parts writen.. so i dont know.. give your director a break..
i thought cindy is playing clarinet, or did brian switch her?

jazz

Posted: Fri Nov 28, 2003 5:55 pm
by Bandnerd89
but one thing i dont get is way some jazz bands want clarinets and others dont. i mean cuz right now im in a jazz band sure i am the only one but i am still here and i play clarinet. and when there isnt a chart for clarinet in most songs there arent then i play the tenor sax part. but the school jazz bands dont want clarinets. does anyone know why that is?

Posted: Sat Nov 29, 2003 6:50 pm
by Hoshwa
euphman wrote:most jazz bands in HS that I've seen have trumpets, trombones, saxes, drum set, bass, guitar.
and piano?

all of those plus piano is what we have.

oh, and vibes.

oh, and we have two drummers so one will pay congas or something, depending on the song.