Mt. Carmel Band Review Results

Topics and polls that cover the overall marching band activity

Moderators: malletphreak, Hostrauser, instrumental director, Trumpet Man 05

Post Reply
User avatar
EmilyD
New Recruit
New Recruit
Posts: 19
Joined: Sat Nov 26, 2011 10:57 am

Mt. Carmel Band Review Results

Post by EmilyD » Sat Oct 24, 2015 3:42 pm

Drum Major Open
1st - 90.3 - Arlington
2nd - 90.2 - Arcadia
3rd - 88.2 - Temescal Canyon
4th - 87.8 - Olympian
5th - 86.7 - Garey

1A Auxiliary
1st - 67.0 - Mt. Miguel
2nd - 64.0 - Granite Hills

1A Band
1st - 78.85 - Granite Hills
2nd - 78.75 - Mt. Miguel
3rd - 58.95 - Morse

2A Auxiliary
1st - 70.3 - Grossmont
2nd - 66.0 - Castle Park

2A Band
1st - 92.8 - Arlington
2nd - 77.4 - Grossmont
3rd - 70.7 - Castle Park

3A Auxiliary
1st - 84.9 - Garey
2nd - 77.8 - Patrick Henry
3rd - 75.2 - Temescal Canyon

3A Band
1st - 91.7 - Garey
2nd - 91.25 - Temescal Canyon
3rd - 86.25 - Patrick Henry

4A Auxiliary
1st - 83.8 - Bonita Vista
2nd - 80.5 - Olympian
3rd - 76.0 - Point Loma
4th - 74.5 - Calexico

4A Band
1st - 91.9 - Olympian
2nd - 91.0 - Bonita Vista
3rd - 83.65 - Point Loma
4th - 82.3 - Calexico

5A Auxiliary
1st - 85.2 - Eastlake

5A Band
1st - 91.05 - Eastlake

6A Auxiliary
1st - 86.1 - Arcadia
2nd - 85.5 - Mira Mesa

6A Band
1st - 92.35 - Mira Mesa

Sweepstakes Auxiliary: Arlington 87.0
Sweepstakes Music: Arcadia 476.0
Sweepstakes Band: Arcadia 94.4

Luis
Section Leader
Section Leader
Posts: 985
Joined: Thu Sep 16, 2004 1:03 pm

Re: Mt. Carmel Band Review Results

Post by Luis » Sun Oct 25, 2015 8:43 am

Great band review. Here are all 17 performances. Enjoy 8-)

Playlist - 39th Annual Mt. Carmel Tournament of Bands

Host - Mt. Carmel HS - The Beau Ideal

94.40 - 6A - Arcadia HS - Bullets & Bayonets
92.80 - 2A - Arlington HS - Emblem of Unity
92.35 - 6A - Mira Mesa HS - Old Ironsides
91.90 - 4A - Olympian HS - Semper Fidelis
91.70 - 3A - Garey HS - The Gallant Seventh

91.25 - 3A - Temescal Canyon HS - Who's Who in Navy Blue
91.05 - 5A - Eastlake HS - Power & Glory
91.00 - 4A - Bonita Vista HS - The Royal Scotch Highlanders
86.25 - 3A - Patrick Henry HS - The Purple Carnival
83.65 - 4A - Point Loma HS - The Gladiator

82.30 - 4A - Calexico HS - King Cotton
78.85 - 1A - Granite Hills HS - Bravura
78.75 - 1A - Mt. Miguel HS - Zacatecas March
77.40 - 2A - Grossmont HS - King Cotton
70.70 - 2A - Castle Park HS - Bravura *5 pen

58.95 - 1A - Morse HS - The High School Cadets *12 pen

NAdrian7
New Recruit
New Recruit
Posts: 16
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2015 7:36 pm

Re: Mt. Carmel Band Review Results

Post by NAdrian7 » Sun Oct 25, 2015 3:27 pm

I was at the Mt. Carmel band review, and what I heard (ontop of the videos provided) as well as the SCSBOA recap lead me to believe that the music scores were grossly inflated across the entire band review. I am very pleased that Mt. Carmel is revisiting "The Beau Ideal" 30 years and two directors later, as well as Arcadia playing "Bullets and Bayonets" on the same street 22 years later. TOTALLY different band I'd say. But, my opinion is that the scores are out of proportion (in the music and showmanship captions) as a whole. Some bands certainly did deserve their scores, for example Arlington did VERY well and probably would rank higher with a more accurate music score, but ALL the music scores were a bit high compared to the quality of the bands AND considering the results that we've been seeing up in the LA area. I guess we'd have to see them all with the same panel to know for sure, and we'll be waiting until the Arcadia Band Review for that :(

Jim Bunselmeier
Veteran
Veteran
Posts: 472
Joined: Tue Sep 27, 2005 11:13 am
Location: Chino, CA

Re: Mt. Carmel Band Review Results

Post by Jim Bunselmeier » Fri Oct 30, 2015 9:52 am

I just watched Arlington's youtube video from the Mt. Carmel parade. This was an outstanding performance from a mid sized band. I saw them on the field earlier this year and I was working with an SCSBOA music perf. sheet while listening. I had them one box higher than the working panel did.

Arlington you are doing a lot of things well. Not many bands your size perform in street and field as well as you do. Keep it up!

Post Reply