Page 1 of 1

Percussion Pit Scoring/GE/Visual/Percussion

Posted: Mon Oct 31, 2011 11:35 am
by saxmaster1
Is there a difference in scoring if Pit members moves around to use other Percussion instrument?

Re: Percussion Pit Scoring/GE/Visual/Percussion

Posted: Mon Oct 31, 2011 11:38 am
by Hostrauser
Shouldn't be. You get credit for what you are playing and how well you are playing it. There aren't bonus points for playing multiple instruments throughout the course of the show.

Re: Percussion Pit Scoring/GE/Visual/Percussion

Posted: Mon Oct 31, 2011 12:15 pm
by BDinkel
Marching band isn't a union gig, the percussion doesn't get double scale for versatility. ;-)

Re: Percussion Pit Scoring/GE/Visual/Percussion

Posted: Mon Oct 31, 2011 2:47 pm
by Brad
Actually, a percussion judge MIGHT look at you doing the multiple assignments, and hold you in higher esteem, which MAY result in a LITTLE bump in the score. Of course, it depends on how well you where handeling the parts. Adding difficulty to a poor performance just gets a score for a poor performance, no bump for diffuculty.

Re: Percussion Pit Scoring/GE/Visual/Percussion

Posted: Mon Oct 31, 2011 3:35 pm
by ODannyBoi
Greg Solomon gave my band a bump in GE score because he appreciated the "box 1" (back when that meant superior) contribution from the pit. 4 musicians playing multiple instruments simultaneously, and well. The rest of his criteria reference were box 3 and low 2, but there was a tiny dash of highlighter in box 1 next to the word "PIT!!", written in ball point, circled and underlined.

Chaffey Field Tournament '09...

sigh... good times.

Re: Percussion Pit Scoring/GE/Visual/Percussion

Posted: Fri Nov 04, 2011 5:08 pm
by Teever
While there is no criteria for a score to be higher specifically because performers can play multiple instruments, it can be reflected in the score in several ways. If the additional timbres used/textures created have a positive effect on the music, then it should result in a higher Repertoire score. If the degree of skill required is significant in the playing of multiple instruments, it should be reflected in the Performance score.

Re: Percussion Pit Scoring/GE/Visual/Percussion

Posted: Sun Nov 06, 2011 2:24 pm
by ODannyBoi
Teever wrote:While there is no criteria for a score to be higher specifically because performers can play multiple instruments, it can be reflected in the score in several ways. If the additional timbres used/textures created have a positive effect on the music, then it should result in a higher Repertoire score. If the degree of skill required is significant in the playing of multiple instruments, it should be reflected in the Performance score.
Yeah.... That's what I meant.
:?